Correlation, Explanation and Consciousness

Margaret Boden

Centre for Research in Cognitive Science
Department of Informatics
Sussex University
Brighton BN1 9QH
East Sussex
UK
maggieb@sussex.ac.uk

Abstract

There s a lot of excitement about brain-scanning evidence for brain/consciousness correlations. Although the evidence is new, the idea isn't: Descartes formulated it nearly 400 years ago. However, he didn't regard mind-brain correlations as explanations  and neither should we. Mere correlation between events in two domains is not enough for the one to be used as an explanation of the other. In addition, we need systematicity, isomorphism, and plausible (ideally, predictive) counterfactual conditionals. There are a few (very few) examples where we already have those features, in respect of correlations between brain events and consciousness. In general, however, they can't be expected. Even where we do have them, they leave the most difficult problem about conscious experience untouched.